Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-28970036-20170312130326/@comment-26815144-20170314211629

Dextrositylight wrote: Also, if you look at Dorwinion's borders they were cut out of Gondor's, on the edge of their borders, not marked out within them, and they only take a small portion of easterling land, the easterlings that are kind of only movie-based or whatever.

They actually take up a portion of Old Rhovanion too, so they're quite a distinct set of people that are more of an after-thought in terms of location.

Dex, the elves are probs minority in Dorwinion, how we know? Well, there are no basic elven troops and they seem pretty cut off from the men.

They would have been loyal to Gondor as they were not the strongest nation compared to Easterlings and Northmen were on good terms with Gondor. Plus loyalty doesn't really matter. As well as the fact no actual lore says their culture except for ethnicities

Lastly, Gondor would take Dorwinion as the sea of rhun was an important trading route.