Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25987328-20160413230109/@comment-26428291-20160415234422

I liked the movies in their own way. While I don't agree with some of what PJ added, I also like the way he built upon what he already had to make to make it more movie-friendly.

Opinions:

Helms Deep. I dislike the fact that the Elves came to Helms Deep, but then when you look at how OP the Uruk-hai were Rohan would've lost. PJ could've made the Uruk-hai less op, but that would've taken away that sense of urgency and last stand.

Tauriel. I like Tauriel's character, but I dislike the love triangle. Tauriel + Legolas is a great match.

BotFA. I liked the movie plot better then the books honestly. The books portray it in a more kid-friendly enviroment, with little detail. The movie added more action.

Sauron & Azog. While I disagree with Azog, I feel like he added to the sense of urgency and the fact the Dwarves were trying to get to the mountains as fast as they could - But I feel that could've been done with Bolg better. I like the part Sauron plays, such as giving a better explanation as to why Gandalf left, and a better purpose to BotFA.

Thranduil. Thranduil is portrayed as a more evil character then he should have been. He was well within his rights to imprison the Dwarves, yet is shown as a semi-bad guy. I like his improvement though in BotFA.

Tom Bombadil. Would've been a nice additon, but the movie works well without him. If he was added people probably would have begged for more of him anyway.