Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-29680750-20170806070151/@comment-25754873-20170810164712

Recneps wrote: How can you say it belonged to Gondor? Because Gondor said it was Gondor? It just looked like some nice, empty land.. Or can you find a quote about them actively dispossessing Gondorians of that land? The Gondorians ruled over it, though it was largly unpopulated. Now, how about you explain why the Dunlendings had the right to move in? In land that they had no claim.