Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-29212138-20170526182111/@comment-25754873-20170527215818

Dolgukhor wrote:  "After the fall of Sauron their race swiftly dwindled or became merged with the Men of Middle-earth..." ― "Appendix A" of The Lord of the Rings

Yes it clearly states only in Umbar.

Well the black numenorean lords were still called thus for a 1 reason they remained black numenoreans, how do they do so without setting up communities?

If thus community lasted formt he taking of umbar to the 35 year siege what makes the communities stop being titled Black Numenoreans?

We know they fled *Maybe to the mountains of Harad* but if so when news reaches them of Umbar's retaking what stops them from coming back?

The natives be their threat, would u be nice to the person whos ancestors enslaved yours?

Made yours live in the dirt due to heavy tribute sthat costed them everything they made. Alright then, let us pretend that in some magical universe that this is completely logical okay? That quote applied to all Numenorean conlonies, save Dol Amroth(and Belfalas) and Minas Anor. It was specificly said in the RotK that they were mostly purebred Dúnedain.

After Gondor took Umbar the second time, the Black Numenoreans never regained lordship of it, as it said the men of Harad retook it, also Tolkien had been specific about the Black Numenoreans peading the earlier attacks so it didn't happen.

They can call themselves Black Numenoreans but in no way shape or form be Black Numenoreans. This is anyways illogical.

The mountains of Harad do not exist in Tolkien's works. Anyways if Umbar was retaken why would the lord the Haradhrim set up yeild over power?

It is said that they intermarried with the natives, anyways 3,000 years of interbreeding would mean that they would have webbed feet and hands.

This last statement is so, unorganised that I can't even make out a general premise of it.