Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-25012056-20141025153920/@comment-27723099-20141031214118

Battling them in Minecraft would be far from realistic. I don't know the Star Wars mod but I don't think that laser shots can one-hit an orc. And their sight range in MC is far below the real range of a laser weapon. Given realistic army proportion for the battle (much more orcs than clone troopers), the orcs would win by numbers.

We must calculate it with much more parameters.

After a few battles, the orcs wouldn't march in big battallions anymore but would instead use stealth and sneak through the terrain. Mordor has enough rifts and rocks to support this. In closecombat, both forces are nearly equal. The clone troopers don't have much training for hand-to-hand combat (I guess) and the orcs have the surprise. Olog-hai could be superior shock troops but they are difficult to use in stealth warfare.

The problem for the orcs is all the special machinery of the clone army. Aircraft would provide the enemy with enough reconnaissance to discover stealth missions and must be quickly taken out by fell beasts or maybe spearthrowers. The smaller AT-walkers are already a challenge, but an AT-AT would be nearly impossible to stop. Catapults don't do much against futuristic armour plates... Only orc bomb at critical weakpoints could do any damage. And to try to deploy them, would be suicide.