Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-28153737-20160626192749/@comment-28153737-20160627033005

EliSuperHero wrote:

JimMoriartyX wrote:

High King Ithilion wrote: Personally, I'm against this, as they aren't mentioned in any later works, and the idea in itself appears to have been abandoned. Also, do note that the movies are considered uncanon.

Ithilion, Discussions Moderator (Auta i lome) 01:55, June 27, 2016 (UTC)

so its perfectly okay to make up a faction to inhabit far harad, but not okay to add a mentioned faction to inhabit Rhun?!

Also, i believe Dorwinion was only mentioned once, but it was okay to add them to Rhun. If uncanon or only mentioned once is not allowed, we better get rid of tauredain and Dorwinion too... What do you mean? Dorwinion im sure is pretty much more canon than ogres will ever be. I'm pretty sure ogres are only fairytale a in middle earth or another name for trolls. Besides, everywhere doesn't need a behemoth npc. Sorry to say this... But I don't really think we need ogres.

and im pretty sure we dont really need Tauredain, but there they are...

at least ogres were actually mentioned...