Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-25869554-20150408184319/@comment-26272311-20150412134532

Thorin Stonehelm wrote: i like BOTFA but it is just to inaccurate to the books for me to say that it is one of my favorite movies, same with the rest of the hobbit trilogy What did you expect!? The writers had like two chapters to work with!

Favorite movie: Return of the King

Favorite scene: When Sam fights Shelob

I like the hobbit movies, but I'll admit, they could have cut all the new stuff (Minus dol guldur, that was a good idea) and made it one movie. Suck  it up, that's what happens when you take a book that is shorter than any of the lotr volumes and try to make it a trilogy of the same length as the lotr films. Plus they intentionally made it so long as to be able to shamelessly sell the extended editions. I'm still buying the extended editions when they come out though, because apparently the main films stink in comparison.