Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-26888709-20160819043034/@comment-26061849-20170318182548

PJ was doomed from the start, in all aspects. Even though Riordan made some good Greek mythology correct, a lot of it is thrown off, or interpreted incorrectly. Tolkien created his own lore, only some of it based off of real lore, and the stuff he based it off of was correct. On characters, there is a vast and diverse amount so great in Tolkien's lore that every Riordan book could not compete, even the ones with Rome. And this isn't even in strength, this is just character-wise and lore-wise.