Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-27810594-20160322230517/@comment-27810594-20160323220321

Recneps wrote:

LOTRGuy wrote:

Forten wrote: I think you're mistaken. An "evil feeling in the air" doesn't mean at all that there is an evil creature floating around in the air making all the good and nice things feel sad. I think you misunderstand. Did you read all three quotes? The first is not vital, but parts such as "As if to keep the sound from unseen listeners in the air", And "Fools! Eyes can see us" when clearly Frodo and Sam do not see anything looking toward them, are hints to something, perhaps not Dementors, but some kind of "Unseen" creature. So, you want something added based on the quote of an insane, paranoid person? Okay, but you are basically saying Gollum is a druggie and a drunk. Gollum obviously is not insane enough as to believe something is not there, because there is no evidence to support this. Gollum could be a trustable source of information, and has never shown to be that insane. He is not a great source of info, because of his untrusibility, but he was scared of this place and obviously believed something was there. Sam also said that he felt as if something with a "Seeing Mind" was inside, he may have been talking about ringwraiths but I believe that nothing points to other Nazgul in Minas Morgul. Don't quote me on that, however. These reasons lead me to believe that Minas Morgul holds "Invisible Creatures".