Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25987328-20160413230109/@comment-26078371-20160426215701

Calanon Evergreen wrote: Kawolski VII wrote: "Were the movies trash?"

That's a very subjective question. What sort of standards are you supposed to judge the movies being "trash" off of?

They had their strong points and weak points, just like any other movie. I cut out the lengthy examples from your reply in the quote, as they are essentially used to back “the movies have their strengths and weaknesses” (which I totally agree with, and I’m sure many).

Kawolski, the basis was set for “were the movies trash”: the assumption that they were only action scenes, full of romance, pure evil, and Peter Jackson ruined them (“sinned”). These are not subjective criteria, since they can be tangibly proven, and were all proven false.

 Elvenking of the Woodland Realm  The arguments were chosen by you and the other people in this thread. You ask someone else and they're going to have different ideas of what's considered trash.