Talk:Eras of Arda: The First Age Server/@comment-47.198.91.62-20170625203029/@comment-26172435-20170626141019

@Ithilion: They could have settled in the Anduin Vales along with other Edain in the course of the First Age. They could have even have come into being there. No sign of both of those readings, or 'alternate' histories, not being possible. No clear evidence of their coming into Arda in the same way or in the same location as the Edain.