Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-27200931-20170402215420/@comment-26149161-20170403001914

Lady Melron wrote: When have Poisoned Orc Scimitars been confirmed by the Mod Team?

Also: you claimed the Scimitars to be OP before, but already knew they were to come either way... so why to take them away from NH, when it makes sense as much sense for them to wield those?

The mod is not full lore-based either, and design wise your armor is just not stunning, Ithilion. If we are to make another bronze based one, let's make it beautiful. You'd better also comprehend that the mod works this way (at least up to this moment): the materials define the strength of the armor. After all, this is the reason why the NH was nerfed, it was made out of a weaker metal.

Meaning that you'd have to elaborate an alternative recipe utilizing bronze in order to have your armor added, and possibly for this recipe you'd either have to create a new alloy for the matter, or combine it with other items, or even have more bronze added to the near-haradrim armour... nonetheless the option given by this suggestion is much simpler.

Also: for whenever you start nitpicking with "canon", realize that Tolkien wished to have others expand his lore in order to keep it anew, since it didn't prejudice his own works, and this suggestion seems to propose that. They haven't, but they are likely to be added due to being a lore feature.

Because, when taken into account with the 25 HP and iron-level armor, the Serpent Warriors are over-strong, seeing as their elite cavalry was taken down by a third their number of Rohirrim.

Subjective. I think my texture looks good, and may others agree with me. This is what it looks like on a player. -->

And that is obviously not true. The Uruk-hai armor is stronger than the Gundabad Uruk armor. The Gondor armor is stronger than the Rohan armor.

Steaming pile of bullsh*t. Tolkien did not want others to expand his work. He annihilated the movie director who tried to, as you might read in Letters. He also disliked his fan groups, not understanding their obsession. The notion that he would want people to add onto it is laughable.

Ithilion, Discussions Moderator (Auta i lome) 00:19, April 3, 2017 (UTC)