Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-27784966-20160224113532/@comment-26347028-20160315074343

Narvin wrote: Just reviewing this thread again. In all its a very well constructed idea. However It's not completely cannon. First of all the actually landmass was called Aman, in which Valinor was only a realm (albeit a very large part of it). The shape of the island was a sort of crescent moon shape. Also I doubt there would be any corrupted Maiar left in valinor after the first age. I doubt the Valar would go all the way to middle earth to destroy melkors forces, but allow them to remain in their own lands. Other than that, it's a great suggestion and I would love to see it implemented. Valinor refers to the inhabited parts of the continent, so a fairly large bit of it; but not all.