Board Thread:Suggestions Forum/@comment-24.240.139.0-20150228230557/@comment-76.247.187.20-20150301234021

WW2 weapons which would work without trouble in Middle Earth are nukes, heavy bombers, most experimental things (1944-1945), and MG's. However, most standard rifles (Kar-98, Lee Enfield, Mosin Nagant) wouldn't work, as their sluggish fire rate would leave their user open to arrows and bolts. In fact, all tanks can be swarmed by elite soldiers, as they might infiltrate it, and hide in positions where they can't be fired upon by MG's or tank cannons. All fast aircraft (Over 300 mph) will work, as virtually nobody can shoot it down, and an arrow won't work well against it.

All SW weapons would work, as climbing any walker is practically impossible, and even if they get in, a crew member will have a blaster, and 1 shot the invader (Blasters shoot plasma, not light). Fighters will easily work, as they have the same reasons as WW2 aircraft. The only primitive working weapons include ramming devices, and swarming the enemy over. An AT-AT is impervious to Olog-Hai, the only thing which will work is Grond. Against SW, magic is useless, as Darth Vader, or Anakin Skywalker (He did in the clone wars) can just choke all people who practice magic, so they can't do anything. Sauron will die, as Yoda will use the force, and levitate the ring into Mount Doom. The Witch King will die, as he won't fall by MEN, and he can fall by droids, or people of other races. Venator class destroyers can just hover over Minas Tirith, and bombard it, while At-ATs just destroy the walls, by shooting it (3 of them wrecked a huge rebel power station + shield generator). Finally, SW has the numerical advantage, better tech, and better skills so they deserve to win.