Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-36922686-20181006154151/@comment-37011877-20181107231247

Gayboi420 wrote: RivkahTinuviel wrote: I think it's logical that this item is only found in the Shire, but a crafting recipe would be nice actually, using a Hobbit CT, as well as the ability to reforge/repair using clay bars. Yes, Aragorn and Gandalf and Saruman and possibly Blue Mountains Dwarves all smoked, but they had traveled and had dealings with the Shire, as mentioned above, so I don't think it can be argued from lore. Just because something is difficult to obtain if you are from an enemy faction is not a valid argument to change that. FT cooldown times are a function of your personal activity, and not an argument for making an item easier to obtain. Otherwise we should make everything spawn everywhere and not have faction-specific or biome-specific items. Most dwarves smoke, have they all had dealings with the Shire? Gondorians smoke, and pipeweed even grows in Gondor, yet they knew so little about Hobbits when Merry and Pippin came that they didn't even know that they were called Hobbits. But surely they've had contact with the Shire! If it's hard to obtain a non-faction-specific item just because of you're faction's allegence, it should be changed, especially something so universally used as a pipe. Nobody said "We need pipes to be everywhere because FT cooldown" as an argument, we just used it to explain how annoying it would be for anybody east of the Misty Mountains to get that simple item.

"Otherwise we should make everything spawn everywhere and not have faction-specific or biome-specific items."

What?? So just because I think that, since I want something we know for a fact that people so far as Gondor used to be more easily obtainable to all factions, I suddenly want everything to spawn everywhere? Bruh, do you know what a "strawman argument" is? Because you basically just redefined it.

Bottom line: Weed is smoked in almost every corner of Middle-earth, and as of now we can only find it in the Shire. I think it would be completely reasonable to be able to find them as far as Gondor and maybe even Harad. There was plenty of weed in Gondor but they just had it as a sweet smelling flower they didn't smoke it. Can you provide any quotes that Gondorians, "most dwarves" or Haradrim smoked?