Thread:Eras of Arda Team/@comment-2601:981:C000:FAE1:D802:DFF0:83DE:82B3-20170809194602/@comment-2601:981:C000:FAE1:D802:DFF0:83DE:82B3-20170809224409

Well considering the choices are he was a whelp for 40 years or he had a 10 year life span I would just say that you could maybe make an exception for him since his origin is a bit foggy. As pointed out in the other thread you have made exceptions for other applications. Especially considiring it is highly probably that Carcharoth was a Maiar.