Thread:Ffets/@comment-27219153-20170511211040/@comment-25565811-20170520084503

''MilkMC wrote: ... ... seems less intuitive to me. I think it requires more memorization ...''

I don't think so, as PAGENAME is the name of the item you want to craft.

''MilkMC wrote: ... "Orcish" crafting table on the Morgul Armour page ... I'm not quite sure what you mean, would you mind explaining it more?''

On the Morgul Armour armour page, the recipe would be only once for each piece using the Orcish Crafting Table which redirects to Category:Orcish Crafting Tables. This would show up on the Angmar Crafting Table, Morgul Crafting Table, etc. as "Orcish crafting recipe". You would be able to see at the first glance, that it's craftable on any of the Orcish tables (like you have it already on the Angmar table).

Btw. here is a very good reason not to have the recipes on the crafting table pages: How do I know, that the Morgul Armour recipes are on the Angmar page? It seems very weird to me to use on the page instead of using

''MilkMC wrote: ... only used 'helmet' instead of 'Rivendell Helmet'. ...''

As we already know, that we deal with Rivendell armour, it's redundant to repeat it and saves a lot of unnecessary typing. Of course, we have to do it for all armours in the same way. As you can see in the template, we can also use alternate notations for each case like "Chestplate", "chestplate", "Tunic" and "tunic".

''MilkMC wrote: ... Golden Rhûnic Armour ... multiple helmets ...''

We have some of those (e.g. Haradric Armour). The logic is to use "Helmet" and "Warlord Helmet" then.

''MilkMC wrote: ... changed ... to be lowercase. ...'' Yep, since I am here (over 2.5 years now), I am fighting unnecessary usage of uppercase. Some articles look really weird. But people capitalize everything that has a link. The problem is that we decided to have the page names capitalized (except for combined words like Wood-elven). So, it's easier to use the capitalized version in the text. In the special case, you linked above, I changed it, because I have all the armour recipes like that and didn't want that one to stand out.

I think, it's a philosophical question, if you consider a "Lindon Helmet" as the name of a special item or a "Lindon helmet" just as a helmet of the Lindon faction.