Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-26888709-20170421085717/@comment-25754873-20170421161006

Eoros wrote: Um... it doesn't, actually. There's a reason every Tolkien scholar uses it.

And since you've never read it, you're in absolutely no place whatsoever to say it's inaccurate. The only one I know of is how she apparently cut 100 miles off of Eriador.