Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-47.41.55.73-20200126012758/@comment-29253515-20200213102127

BlueGoldenRose wrote: Actually, Sauron couldn't control all beasts easily. As well as that, perhaps the Graugs and Caragors were currently being bred, as in they were low in population. Therefore, they would most likely generally reside solely in Mordor.

And you exaggerated their capabilities, as they, in fact, were obviously not able to PICK UP an Olog-hai and eat them. They certainly, however are stronger, yet that would also help support the fact that Sauron was attempting to breed them to obtain a more fearsome creature. This is further supported by the fact that there are Olog-Graugs which would mean that they are DEFINITELY being bred to be powerful but smarter.

I know there's no way most people consider this suggestion anymore... Which is mostly based on bias, but the more I argue for it, the more it makes sense that it would be a pretty good idea rather than simply a sub-par one.

Sure, there's yet to be things that we're all looking forward to, such as Mumakil, but these are much smaller creatures and aren't as difficult to implement (Caragors are rather small, and Graugs are similar to trolls, to where the details could mesh together in minecraft).
 * Actually, Sauron couldn't control all beasts easily. As well as that, perhaps the Graugs and Caragors were currently being bred, as in they were low in population. Therefore, they would most likely generally reside solely in Mordor.*

This is not what we see ingame so your just making stuff up about them (which is fine because they are fan fiction) but you truly belief frodo did not come across it. No one mentioned it during the SEVEN YEAR siege of barad dur (would have been a great time to use them) or when Aragorn was waiting at the gate.


 * And you exaggerated their capabilities, as they, in fact, were obviously not able to PICK UP an Olog-hai and eat them. They certainly, however are stronger, yet that ​​​​​​​would also help support the fact that Sauron was attempting to breed them to obtain a more fearsome creature. This is further supported by the fact that there are Olog-Graugs which would mean that they are DEFINITELY being bred to be powerful but smarter.*

Did you play the games??? Graugs litteraly pick up and eat Olog Hai in it. Also the olog-graugs are not a mix between a olog hai and graug, just a more powerfull graug.

If you mean bias for lore friendlyness than definitly yes.
 * I know there's no way most people consider this suggestion anymore... Which is mostly based on bias, but the more I argue for it, the more it makes sense that it would be a pretty good idea rather than simply a sub-par one.*

​​​​​​​  Graig size next to olog hai in game     ->