Board Thread:Suggestions Forum/@comment-25672535-20150214040227/@comment-26116279-20150220133008

Actually only a select few mortals who went to valinor would become immortal the vast majority if they went would die more quickly kind of like being burnt out Earendil was a half elven and Frodo, Sam, and gimili were special execptions to the normal rule and were given the fate of the eldar. Frodo and ssam because they bore the one ring and i'm not exactly sure why gimli was allowed. Also not all of Utumno was opened and emptied because there were so many hidden chambers and caverns and it was so large that not even the valar destroyed all of it. Also Aragorn did not choose when to die he knew he was about to die so he went and fell asleep and died in his sleep like the original kings of Numenor.