Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-43561261-20191113211524/@comment-30830745-20191115135719

Aragost02 wrote: Technically this is on WntS (no suggesting Main quests). Also, wasn't it that only a king of Gondor could command them? I haven't read the books in a long while, and I only read them once, so I'm basing this off the movies. Even more exclusive: only Aragorn could have commanded them, prophesied by Malbeth the Seer.

So, why make them vulnerable by giving them an HP Bar? The canonical Dead Men of Dunharrow were impotent, but still fearsome. They drove the Umbarians from Lamedon to Pelargir not by sword, but by the pure horror of their presence. They are merely haunts trapped in Eä because their king broke an oath to the King of Gondor.

Jurassic Sean  of Tol Hîth  Visit my Park!