User blog comment:Dark Lord Mairon/Could Arda be Our World before it was created?/@comment-26453572-20150903213643

First of all, Tolkien was a devout Catholic, and even added some elements of Catholicism into his books, which rules out this theory. Second of all, didn't you say you were an athiest? You bring up God and Heaven quite a bit, and there's small part of me that wonders if you're mocking religion (in particular, Christianity).