Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-25012056-20141025153920/@comment-50.36.65.10-20150114220613

If we're talking Orc vs. GAR, then the GAR (Grand Army of the Republic) wins, hands down. Sorry, Orcs. But if lasers can vaporized battle droids, then the Orcish armor stands no chance. Maybe a Mithril platemail suit would work...Of course, the Valar and Maiar are indestructible (Their spirits can never be destroyed by any means of Middle Earth), but they mostly dwell in Valinor, and those who are in Middle Earth are either very weak (Sauron) or restricted in power-use (The Istari). But GAR vs. ALL Lord of the Rings creatures, well...The nearly indestructible dragons can probably take a few turbolaser hits before dying, and you physically can't kill Ainur or Iluvatar, at least not when the Ainur are supported by Iluvatar, who you just can't kill regardless. Even the Jedi and their Torrent, LAAT/I, and Y-Wing support are no match for Gandalf, Radagast, and the Great Eagles. Especially not if the Eagles of Manwe come to join the party. Because those Eagles are pretty much indestructible.

All in all, it depends on who's doing the fighting.