Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-30238907-20170118132644/@comment-122.60.109.148-20170125204605

Yes, Mevans has previously added factions and regions that did not have a solid basis in lore. But in those instances, he invented only reasonable additions. The factions and regions added by him make sense, like a version of Haradrim living in the jungles, and the geography of the lower part of the continent. This suggestion, however, makes little sense, no matter how detailed it is or how fun it would be to visit these islands. We already have randomly spawning islands, and Mevans, in his infinite wisdom, has neglected to add a faction of island-dwellers. The islands are random because the logical conclusion is that islands probably existed in Arda, but we have no idea where any of them where, and all the sentient races lived in either Endor or Aman. The race of Men, who I assume these island people would be of, were never recorded to have journeyed east from the continent of Endor, as these must have done to establish island nations (after all, the origin of men was in Endor, not these supposed islands).