Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-28153737-20160626192749/@comment-28153737-20160627020846

High King Ithilion wrote: To quote the FAQ:

" "If Far Harad Factions are non-canon, why can't we add (non-canon suggestion)?"

The West of Middle-Earth is fully fleshed out in the lore, so keep suggestions for here canon. While the Far Harad tribes are non-canon, they do make sense, and so do the planned Rhunic Clans. They are seen as better than not having Harad or Rhun at all, as the canon material for said regions is limited. Please keep the suggestions for Far Harad, Rhun, and the Dark Lands either to a minimum or post ways to improve existing factions. This means no Dwarves in Far Harad or the Dark Lands, no Snow-elves, in infinitum. "

Ithilion, Discussions Moderator (Auta i lome) 02:02, June 27, 2016 (UTC)

so why exactly cant ogres be a thing, like tauredain? also, morgoths evil stayed in the northwest, so where did half trolls come from? Ogres, as i suggested, would be more like Half-trolls than normal trolls.

And we cant suggest Rhun additions because non canon clans are planned...

what clans? whenever someone mentions easterlings, they are told that easterlings are not planned yet, but you say that we cant suggest them because non canon clans have already been planned. which is it? are they planned out already or not? we've been told two different things...