Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25987328-20160413230109/@comment-27704072-20160416004920

The Indomitable wrote: The movies failed miserably to convey the depth of the living, breathing world of Middle Earth. Sure, it had good fights, and such. But, it amounted to a pile of flimsy (rancid) garbage heaped around a few battles. That is the one, major problem that makes any movie based on books, or comics worse than said books, or comics. I completely agree, although the LOTR fimls weren't as bad as the Hobbit films. Also we shouldn't pan PJ too much since he broadend the LOTR fan base and his films encouraged more people to read the books.