Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25987328-20160413230109/@comment-27704072-20160416005755

Jakespacepirate wrote: The Indomitable wrote: The movies failed miserably to convey the depth of the living, breathing world of Middle Earth. Sure, it had good fights, and such. But, it amounted to a pile of flimsy (rancid) garbage heaped around a few battles. That is the one, major problem that makes any movie based on books, or comics worse than said books, or comics. Well, Middle-Earth isnt real...so, you can see how hard it might be to "make it real". :/ Tolkien made it as close to real as can be.