Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-27860585-20160227122451/@comment-26347028-20160311010123

Catfishperson wrote: He manipulated the Noldor into revolt against Aman and the pointless murder of their own kin! He then proceeded to lead them to their deaths in Middle Earth(along the way he abandoned his brother and a hoast of kin, and burnt the ships of the Teleri, the likes of which the earth has never seen since, just to ensure their deaths.) He then swore the oath of Feanor, fully aware of the dire consequences, which brought about the Doom of Mandos, and in case you forgot, the Doom of Mandos was the reason that the hosts of Valinor didn't come to "Save-the-day" in the 1st, 2nd and 3rd ages, which cost countless lives, meant the corruption of men (and some dwarves), and was the destruction of many, many fair things. If you can name one orc, dwarf or man who did more damage then that. I will be very surprised. Heck... he even caused more damage then Sauron. 'He caused more damage' specifies it being direct. Directly, he cause the deaths of few. Indirectly, Melkor was a much larger cause than he was.