Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-29979363-20170120203844/@comment-26322120-20170122224429

99.224.12.148 wrote: Arachor wrote: Nope. They only burned people with evil deeds, such as Melkor and the two sons I mentioned.

Beren was never burned either, he lost his hand to Charcaroth, not the silmaril. Actually, they burned those who were mortal or evil.

I am fairly certain that they only burned people who acquired them through evil means.