Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-27324018-20151211222735/@comment-27324018-20160413030006

101.165.3.159 wrote: I know but I thought it might be a fun piece of fiction you might enjoy reading :P

Personally I think Stargate would beat them all in terms of insanely powerful tech but if we're sticking to topic, then Star Wars would win in terms of having superior engines (hyperdrives better than warp), but in terms of shields strength, ship production, exotic abilities...Star Trek wins. Star Trek weapons are more efficient than Star Wars but the latter has significantly higher firepower. Firepower is nothing. Star Trek weapons do not operate on the same principle as Star Wars weapons, and Picard once scoffed that a laser weapon "wouldn't even penetrate our navigational shields". Star Trek shields are capable of deflecting antimatter explosions at close range. I saw a Star Destroyer completely taken out by one blast from an ion cannon. There wouldn't be any issue if they even used magnetic shielding. A Star Destroyer can execute Base Delta Zero? The Federation has a trilithium device that can make a healthy G-type star go nova. And they certainly don't need a "Starkiller Base" to do it. This probe is less than 5 feet long.

As for speed, Star Wars has always manifested extreme problems with their feasibility. Solo can do the Kessel Run in 12 parsecs? What, he has a warp drive that can shorten the distance involved? The Falcon will do .5 past lightspeed? That's nice. Not only do Federation starships do approximately 500c at normal cruising speed, they can triple that when they need to. And you can believe me, they don't need astromech droids to repair their FTL drive when it goes wonky.

But the Federation has nothing on the Borg. The Borg can do about 60,000c through their transwarp conduits. And they even open up transdimensional portals to attack brand new universes when they feel like it.

"Don't be too proud of this technological terror you've constructed. The ability to destroy a planet is insignificant next to the power of the Force." Perhaps. But the Q cannot be stopped except by other Q, while the Jedi can be completely stopped by a creature so insignificant as a ysalamiri.

As for Doctor Who, I can't tell whether it's supposed to be serious sci-fi or just a comedy show for the 12-year-old girls who have a crush on David Tennant. Not worth the comparison, that's for sure.