Thread:Eras of Arda Team/@comment-84.107.251.243-20170718202517/@comment-31996723-20170725190545

It was well written here the second time, but before you had posted this revised version another player applied for the same role and his application were just as good if not better. Imagine if you had two applications, one player was posted his before the other and the other was posting the same application for the second time because he/she did a no-go thing and posted a direct copy from a wiki, meaning you would lose a lot confidence in said person, because the act of said person sort of showed you he/she was not willing to make a proper application for a lore role, most certainly not for a leader role. In this case, which person would you then choose?

The other player got the role as we are confident in his capabilities as Círdan. He has done nothing to prove us otherwise. This of course does not mean you couldn't have been a good Círdan, but your last move did not exactly give us much confidence in you when we had to pick between two good applications - being your application or his application. Hopefully you have learned your lesson from your last move. You were most definately on the right track with this new application.

Best regards, the Lore Administration.