User blog comment:SamwiseFilmore/New Suggestions System EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY/@comment-26172435-20160303184301

Uhm ... why give the impression this concerns a new suggestions system, which will be EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY ... while the text includes a 'proposal' and you're asking for people's opinions?

I'm missing quite a bit of info, so I cannot judge 'the idea' in its entirety yet. I'll just assume more gets added along the way. A few issues that come to mind:

My suggestions have all been collected on my user page. Copy-paste to a new page will be easy for me ... but how will people find, 'rate' and discuss them? And how will it work for new suggestions? Add polls for each suggestion on the user pages? What will be the fate of the current approved and non-approved suggestions, and those that were highly valued but removed in last cleanout, and the proposals listed in the LoD? Will we just leave them there for everyone's enjoyment and inspiration?

As far as my feedback on the procedure/system goes: I guess you've had your share. Anything relevant discussed in the community can be found here, and all my views and proposals are compiled here.

I'll comply with anything you guys come up with, just make sure its clear and conclusive.