Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-28440866-20160912175238/@comment-26556622-20160919175518

I don't agree with the light of earendil being found on meneltarma... honestly it's just the light of a star/silmaril. The phial from the movies was a magical contraption made by Galadriel specifically for Frodo. And since Galadriel never set foot on Númenorë I strongly doubt if there would be anyone there that has magical abilities that are even near Galadriel's powers. I mean next to her affinity with magic (that most children of Finarfin seem to have) she was most likely taught by the very best, the maiar. In perticular Melian. With whom she lived for many years.