Thread:Eoros/@comment-29212138-20170421153052/@comment-28794147-20170421175828

When you have tons of orcs, it's incredibly difficult not to surround them. That's not strategy in the slightest.

I also think Aragorn should've used the Black Gate as a choke point. Not only that, but it would've made it seem as if Aragorn was being even more reckless by literally nearly stepping into his land.

If he used the Black gate as a choke point, he would've done like Rome. Form into 2 or 3 wedges, have your back line prepared to fend off attacks from the rear if they came, and plow down the enemy.

Even if the Olog-hai were smart, thousands of heavy infantry would've been able to take them down. Especially if the orcs were weak and ill prepared for such a battle.