Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-32100148-20170814073925/@comment-29773086-20170815070627

The closest island I can think of to the criteria is Girdley Island, in the Brandywine, as it is in Eriador and connected to the Hobbits.. But even that is clearly not the subject of this suggestion, as it was neither mentioned in The Silmarillion nor inhabited by a short people, as far as we know. The only way we can know is if Nomomhom chooses to elaborate.