Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-27860585-20160227122451/@comment-26347028-20160301203943

MrHobit1234 wrote: Zombielizard wrote: Dwrves would have won in the Botfa if not for th orcs bringging them together in the movie (and before you say that's not cannon, I say the book gives us the first 3 mins of the battle says bilbo is knocked out thorin kili and fili die and the it's 2 days later) So the only real soild info we have is from the movie (in the extended edition the dwarves bring ballista, notably turning the battle in their favor look it up)

Basically I'm saying if dwarves and elves fought then dwarves would win.

They are just more adapt for melee! Are you kidding me the MOVIES ARE NOT CANNON! Their where only 500 dwarves while their where thousands of hundred year old elves They're much more than a hundred years old. An age, at least, which is 3,000 or so years.