Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-26092363-20160126084604/@comment-26044072-20160126225828

High King Ithilion wrote: No... the first elves were born in Cuivinen, and then more were born elsewhere. Saying all elves are from Cuivinen is like saying all humans are from Africa.

That is a theory though that we all are from Africa and spread outwards from there, also yes most were born else where whatever. But still he was saying that the noldor are the most ancient when the Teleri and Vanyar have been around for just as long.