Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25565811-20160116225008/@comment-27723099-20160118081935

Ffets wrote: Sinthoniel wrote: Athelas is not renewable. Wrong, athelas now grows when bonemeal is used on meneltama grass. Ah yes, I forgot about that.

With so many renewable items, maybe we could make a Middle Earth Skyblock map?

@AlteOgre

I consider all of your points as renewable, except treasure chest loot (because the chests are not renewable). It is a common practise to build farms that kill mobs for items, including stuff for the unsmeltery. This way you can get tons of metal without ever going in a mine.

Traders are the borderzone. A limited world has only a limited number of non-travelling traders, which means it is not sure that all possible sale offers exist. That means technically normal trader offers are not in every world renewable. Travelling trader offers are renewable.