Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-30567038-20171107131815/@comment-25841881-20171107230016

Also, for practical suggestion purposes.. The Silmarillion could be considered canon. He was working on later revisions, but that was the case for all of his life. The Silmarillion, while some parts are slightly mangled, gives an accurate representation of what would be known in the Third Age about the events of the Earlier Days. As such, suggestions for the Third Age don't need to account for the revisions of the First Age portion of the Legendarium.