Board Thread:Suggestions Forum/@comment-25672535-20150214040227/@comment-50.36.65.10-20150220131048

The point is not that Men, Dwarves, or Hobbits would die faster if they went to Aman, in fact, it is the opposite-they, like Earendil, would become immortal, because the Powers that dwell there have "hallowed" the land. However, the Valar are prohibited from taking the Gift of Men from them, and can therefore not allow (many) Men to become immortal. The exceptions to this rule are of course the half-elven, such as Elrond and his immediate kin, i.e. Elrond, Elros (before he died), Elrohir, Elladan, and Arwen. Aragorn is too far separated from the blood of the Elves to have the choice of his doom, save his ability to choose the hour of his own death. The Utumno idea is not good, because in the T.A. and Fo.A., well, Utumno shouldn't even exist, canon-wise. Utumno's deepest pits were opened, emptied, and destroyed. But, anyway, anything that found the ruins and dwelled there once more would be completely evil, evil enough to kill anything. But access to Aman should, canon-wise, only be granted with A. INCREDIBLE, Frodo-like friendship with the Elves. B. Incredible accomplishment (Which means Gollum should be admitted to Aman, I mean, after all, he DID finish Frodo's quest), and C. A nice boat-trip with an Elf, to prevent you from getting lost in the Sundering Seas. (Elves alone can take the Straight Way to reach Aman)