Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25565811-20160116225008/@comment-27723099-20160118082804

For me, Renewable is the strict question "Can you somehow produce it infinitely using only the resources of a finite world?" or in other words "Can you somehow produce it using only renewable items, blocks, or entities?".

In vanilla, this tag should give an estimation of the value of an item. Even in vanilla it is misleading because dirt, the least valuable resource, is not renewable. Skyblock (and similar games) are the only situation I can think of where renewability really matters.

If more people agree with this, I will remove the tag.