Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25987328-20160413230109/@comment-26094355-20160425182324

Catfishperson wrote: I say that fight scenes are necessary in a fantasy film, but shouldn't be the fantasy film. And TBOFA was just a fight scene. Nothing more. I agree that TBOFA was an important battle, I would not call it defining though (Based off of Tolkien's ME. To base it from its own standards would require circular logic.) I am not trying to use CinemeaSins as basis that the Hobbit Films were instantly trash, I was using it to illustrate some of the Plot Holes. You're just repeating yourself. I already displayed how fight scenes are actually necessary, especially for a film about the last leg of The Hobbit tale (the Battle of Five Armies). FusRohDah666 kindly pointed out that even Battle of the Five Armies wasn't completely a "fight scene", like you seem to think.

The romance and "action only" points are pretty much addressed and disproved. If you have nothing new to bring to the table, I suggest you concede, since I don't like beating the dead horse.

 Elvenking of the Woodland Realm