Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-26088681-20171011203808/@comment-26088681-20171012161048

Yeah I tend to agree with Hobit. There are indeed good and evil: as Hobit said, evil is fundamentaly weaker than good, and cannot create but only corrupt and seduce. It's a mid way between Manicheism and Christian philosophy. Boromir is as everyone originally good: but he ends up being seduced by the ring and then repents. And about Saruman, he was seduced by a greater power, but was good in the beginning.

As for the point of this thread, I created this because I was wondering myself if hating Shadow of War because it disrespected Tolkien's work was really a valid ground.

Is it because Shadow of War totally changes the philosophy of Tolkien and transform it to fit into our western world that it doesn't deserve consideration?