Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-26371213-20150704180818/@comment-25288333-20150705150020

James of the iron hills wrote:

Starplayer11111 wrote:

Sinthoniel wrote: LordDainTheAwsome wrote: Yes! It should take at least 3 Mordor orcs to take one down! No it shouldn't. Only because the soldiers of Gondor are shown to be very strong and good equipped in most adaptions, doesn't mean it's true. I think only very good fighters could win against 3 orcs at once. The soldiers of Gondor were better than the orcs of Mordor, but not much. In the mod, both have nearly equal stats, but orcs get significant debuffs in the sunlight. It's obvious that Mordor has a great advantage during the night, but it's noting more than to be equally strong as Gondor. In addition to that, there are orc skirmishes, able to break Mordor armies even before the battle has started.

The great effectiveness of the army of Gondor was not just becasue the troops had better quality but also because they had good leaders, good morale and good strategies. In most battles, they defended fortifications (Osgiliath, walls of Minas Tirith) or surprised the enemy (Faramir's ambush, Aragorn's arrival and the counterattack of Dol Amroth during the Battle on the Pelennor Fields). Well right now one soldier of gondor cannot even take on 2 orcs, even one by one.

Also in great field battles against mordor, gondorian soldiers were able to beat enemy hosts more than fives times their size. Which open filled battles? Which book? There were some soldiers that were indeed well trained but others weren't that great. Not every Gondorian soldier can take on two or even one orc.