Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-26322120-20160128003033/@comment-25612015-20160131211215

Catfishperson wrote: we should make an official page on this wiki, for every major structure, where people can post pictures of their own renditions [...] We could also post information such as lore, location, building tips, and non-minecraft images. Glaerdir wrote: I don't think player builds should belong on this wiki. Well, we were not talking about random player builds, but major structures builds, which are obviously of interest to many  people on this wiki and to many mod users.

These pages could be seen as a duplication of contents with the One Wiki to Rule Them All, unless people stuck with Catfish' suggestions for information above.

Glaerdir wrote: What I advise you to do is create a seperate wiki just for that. Ffets wrote: This wiki should be about what's already included in the mod, not what's not. Perhaps what's planned in the (near) future. But that's it. Perhaps the main header template should be changed because it states that this is "a public wiki for everything related to the Lord of the Rings Mod". It might be best then to write that it is "for everything included in"?

Still, this advice to go create a separate wiki is disturbing to me. The community gathered around this mod is already beginning to fragment with the departure of its founder, and the creation of separate wikis such as The Black Archives or ForgottenCraft. Is this really what you want?

If the only purpose here is to present reference information about the mod, and not doing anything together, then using the term "community" should indeed be avoided. Better speak about keepers and visitors.

Regards,