Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-172.56.12.28-20190729103652/@comment-39689697-20190729114510

User 172.56.12.28, you don't seem to quite understand what the First and Second Ages had in them.

The First Age began after the two trees of Valinor were destroyed by Melkor and Ungoliant. In fact it only began at the first rising of the sun, by which stage, as User 90.71.54.237 pointed out, the Dwarves and Orcs were already been established and the Men had just woken up. It is immensely interesting and the focus of nearly the whole Quenta Silmarillion. Don't try to tell me the Narn i Chin Hurin is boring!

In the Second Age, Arnor would likely not be included at all,as it didn't exist until aftr the downfall of Numenor. As such, the Numenorean Empire would likely take centre stage in a Second Age dimension. Personally, I think a F.A. Dimension would be far more interesting than a S.A. one, as the S.A. would include only the Faithful and King's Men Numenoreans along with Eregion as new factions, with all others being earlier versions of those which still exist in the T.A. A dimension based on the F.A. would feature Beleriand and all its many realms.

Finally, I would like to point out that discussing these dimensions is a nice thought experiment, but that these dimensions are possibly decades away from being added as the T.A. is far from completion. Also User 90.71.54.237, you don't want to get your hands on a Silmaril. Beren was called Erchamion for a very good reason!