Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-29979363-20170120203844/@comment-26556622-20170121101525

74.65.212.102 wrote: Thorin said the Dwarves of Erebor mined the Arkenstone out from under the Mountain.

But is the Phial of Galadriel a Silmaril of Feanor... No of course not, it's not even stone mate. How can you possibly think that a phial made of crystalline glass capped with silver and clearly filled with water equals a burning holy gemstone?