Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-29212138-20170526182111/@comment-29773086-20170527000644

Dolgukhor wrote: "...the Men of Harad, led by the lords that had been driven from Umbar. came up with great power against that stronghold..." - Appendix A

That proves the Numenorean lords were driven from Umbar and came back intact as they led the wild men of Harad. So they survived as a community themselves.

What do u mean? there has never been any lorebacking of a Blakc Numenorean community in Mordor

but there has in Umbar, so yes it is way more logical of him to be from Umbar. U act as if Castamir's Sons were the only dunedian brought to Umbar.

Umbar was lost to harad from a rebellion by the more populas haradrim in the region it was not planned that Castamir would just caus ethe kin strife.

Whos said all left it? Even if they didnt they wouldnt have been slaughtered, it wouldnt have been liek the french revolution as they executed all rich families in cold blood. You, my friend, have reached the very heights of stupidity. That quote is after the first conquest of Umbar by Gondor. It was taken twice after that, not including the times that Castamir and the Haradrim gained control.