Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-31382381-20170225024029/@comment-26149161-20170227215007

- It's the most likely option, and no more speculative than your claim that they might have survived.

- There was a pass in South Mordor at the Nargil. Furthermore, they over time fell into worshipping Sauron above Pharazon. Finally, they also would have left in the event of the three or more Gondor occupations, where they would be wanted men.

- We're told the blood was diluted far faster than in Gondor. If the Numenorean blood was rare in Gondor, it would be extinct in Umbar. We also know that the Haradrim held Umbar, and the Corsairs were a faction of them. Wouldn't the Numenoreans be in charge otherwize?

- They fell into the Shadow and worshipped Sauron and Morgoth.

- Any Black Numenorean family under Gondorian rule would likely be killed or driven out. They would flee to Mordor, or into the Harad, and either join Sauron or mingle with Haradrim.

Ithilion, Discussions Moderator (Auta i lome) 21:50, February 27, 2017 (UTC)