Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-26149161-20160302133927/@comment-27587913-20160304044137

Still though! All proof point to this taking place at least 2 years after Bilbo's Birth day! look at the happening of the book, day after bilbo's pary Gandalf leaves and says he will return soon, one year later Frodo and Sam leave any way, Gandalf escapes from Isengaurd and Saruman starts to plan an attack on the world of men, another few months later and the Uruk-hai are born. so stop thinking this is the day after Bilbo's party, on that day Isengaurd Still had trees and what not! Radagast told Gandalf to go there so it is highly unlikely he went there saw Uruk-hai and returned to gandalf unharmed