Thread:Eras of Arda Team/@comment-32577983-20170715214352/@comment-26428291-20170719050929

204.112.207.91 wrote: The "being a pup" reason in kind of unfair, since you are allowing someone to be Huor, who isn't even born yet. Ok, you make a good point.

Huor was born in 444, Carcharoth 'became' Carcharoth in 466. Before then, he was still a pup, or a whelp. I doubt that it would take a werewolf/warg very long to grow to adulthood, maybe no more than 3 years. Therefore, Carcharoth probably wasn't very old when Morgoth found him and fed him up. Huor, on the other hand, was (as I said) born in 444, which is just within reasonable time. '''I want to make this very clear: this 'timeframe' is only for us Lore Administrators to use when we can't decide on an application. It does not give you guys reason to apply for characters who were born past the year 400.''' Sorry if I contradicted myself in any way. The answer is stil no, sorry.