Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-30980630-20180711162404/@comment-27587913-20180714170442

SteelLord2 wrote: Zombielizard wrote: I'd say this is lore innaccurate, Elven, Dwarven, and to a lesser extent Uruk steels all fill the purpose as "Steel that is better than Steel", no Human could possibly compete with the smiths of the Elves and Dwarves. Infact, I would not be surprised if, (had tolkein been well versed in forging techniques), he had made Dwarves and Elves use Crucible Steel. The problem is that there is to little space between stats, so you can't say this is not as good as uruk, elvish or dwarven stell but it is a very good sword for men, you can only say it's as good as uruk, elvish or dwarven steel or not. which is pretty much the problem, this steel has to fit into a place which can't exist.