Board Thread:Suggestions Forum/@comment-72.186.237.217-20141221021624/@comment-27723099-20141221031237

This is not true. Eru exists outside of Arda but when an elf dies, he comes to Mandos' Halls. Mandos is a Valar who is responsible for those who died. Mandos' Halls are in Aman, the land of the Valar. It was Mandos (and the other Valar) who sent Gandalf (and others) back from death.