Thread:LOTRMod/@comment-25012056-20150119223034/@comment-25101089-20150122002853

I thank you very much for the enormous amount of work this must have been, but... this just isn't the kind of suggestion that's very helpful to me.

This more resembles a wish list than anything else. Just a huge long list of line after line that makes me feel like I'm drowning in suggestions.

I mean, yes, there are some simple suggestions on there that only need to be one line, but what about things like (for example, the first few I saw) Clearly there has been no thought put into these suggestions. They're all pretty obvious ideas, and they all also have some pretty obvious issues that would need to be worked out if they were added. Someone just thought 'Hey! That would be good in the mod!' and rushed to the wiki to dump it on us without any further thought or effort on their part, it seems.
 * Right-clicking fruit tree leaves gives one fruit.
 * Hireable dwarven miners.
 * Plantable mallorn nuts.

And of the more simple suggestions e.g. new blocks, mobs, features, structures (again I hate to say but a great deal of these are also pretty obvious ideas and have been asked for pretty often) if the suggester can't even take the time to elaborate a little on what the basic uses and mechanics of the suggestion would be, I'll probably just discount it.

Again, thank you for your work in compiling these lists (I know you're not the ones who wrote the suggestions so my complaints aren't directed at you) but really somewhere like that is the last place I'd want to look if I wanted to get some ideas on what to add. I already have far too much to add as it is and wish lists are more a hindrance than a help.

But I suppose it's better to have a lot of useless enthusiastic suggestions than a lack of any enthusiasm at all.