Thread:Eras of Arda Team/@comment-2601:981:C000:FAE1:D802:DFF0:83DE:82B3-20170809194602/@comment-2601:981:C000:FAE1:D802:DFF0:83DE:82B3-20170809215510

Just because Cacharoth had no major feats in the time before Sauron and his minions were defeated Huan and Luthien doesn't mean he was alive. Its just that at that time he started being trained to take down Huan. According to where you are putting his birth, he would have had less than a 10 year lifespan, as he died in 466. According to the wiki he was born before the creation of Arda so he was most likely a maiar and most definitely in existence at 400 FA.