Thread:Eras of Arda Team/@comment-2601:981:C000:FAE1:D802:DFF0:83DE:82B3-20170809194602/@comment-29773086-20170809204236

On this thread it was established that Carcharoth either did not yet exist or was a whelp, and therefore not eligible to be roleplayed as.

As seen in this timeline, Sauron captured Minas Tirith in 457. The whole reason for Melkor mutating Carcharoth was that Sauron and his minions were defeated by Huan and Luthien. Do you seriously believe that Carcharoth was a pup for over 57 years?