Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-34435400-20180124152047/@comment-29773086-20180128191234

Yeah, the ancestors of the Dunlendings did not dwell in Gondor, only a people related to them. Gondor, perhaps, wronged that people when they claimed sovereignty over Calenardhon. But not Dunland. Then, after some time, Gondor grew weak, and Calenardhon unpopulated. Dunland invaded Calenardhon. After Eorl the Young saved Gondor, Cirion gave the Rohirrim the lands stolen by Dunland- if they could extricate the Dunlendings, which they did. I don't see how Dunland is in the right there.