Thread:Eras of Arda Team/@comment-84.107.251.243-20170716091533/@comment-67.255.66.154-20170716151823

Look, I love that you took the time to create a custom character, and I really feel kinda bad about what I'm about to do, but I must.

Tolkien originally wrote that the Valar had children, he later abandoned this idea; he actually wrote that the Valar did not have children, there is an article about this but I don't think it is needed, I do believe that he said that there were not Valar children because he created the valar as spirits, although he made them male and female he did not make their species have a gender, and thus they could not have children.

Of course I could be wrong, so PLEASE, feel free to correct me or discuss this more, I really love that you weren't afraid to take some "creative liberties" when making your custom character, but I think that making a Valar child sort of contradicts (or is contradicted by) Tolkien's writings.

Again, please feel free to respond or correct me.

Dr_Taco