Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-29145474-20160809014118/@comment-26834366-20160818021207

Forten wrote: Lord Epicus! wrote:

Rayn Turammarth wrote:

Lord Epicus! wrote:

Rayn Turammarth wrote: Eru vs. the Emperor-over-Seas can't really be contested, as they both represent God. Aslan would have the same amount of power as Manwë or Melkor. To contest Maia Narnia has Witches.

You could also say that every 'good' Narnian is invincible, because Aslan sent them to Heaven. You could try make the argument that Eru revived Gandalf, but that only happened once.

LotR Elves however are also 'invincible', but only after an extended period of time. Narnians were 'reborn' almost immediately after death, as seen with King Caspian. Witches arent a counter to maiar, they are counters to black numenoreans. Witches were immortal and were capable of performing magic. Black Númenoreans were not. I didn't mean it as in 'Witches are Narnian Angels'. Some black numenoreans were sorcerers I believe. But I didnt know narnia witches were immortal though. Who needs sorcerors when there are possibly hundreds of Maiar within Arda? Tulkas or Melkor would wreck Aslan's ass. Anyway, apart from Maiar, there is very, very little magic in Middle-earth. The only true magic stems from Maiar. I just assumed that narnia witches were just sorcererers, I had no clue they were immortal. Thats why I didnt compare them to Maiar.