Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-33009418-20170922084807/@comment-25754873-20171010114922

Assassin of Harad wrote: High King Ithilion wrote: No, that's not how it works. Denethor was perfectly competent at leading: he was proud, strategic, commanding, and dedicated to maintaining the glory of Gondor. To say he was anything less, and to even suggest that opposing him is good, is absurd. He was never some evil madman as the films made out.

Furthermore, the reason for the Kin-Strife wasn't politics, it was racism. They were uncomfortable with a king of Northmen heritage, and so rebelled. Not that their leader was incompetent or anything like that. Overall, it's ridiculous to suggest anyone would oppose the throne of Denethor, and rebellions should not be implemented for the greatest kingdom of Men.

Ithilion, Discussions Moderator (Auta i lómë) I don't agree with the last part. Just because Gondor is the greatest kingdom of Men, there can't be rebellions? There were rebellions in every empire of the world ... It was impossible for Gondorians to have anything of this sort, Harad however....