Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-26429944-20151013121131/@comment-26444332-20151013183928

I truly enjoyed your suggestion, even if it was a bit hard to make out. I would appreciate more punctuation and more correct grammar, as it makes it much easier to read and understand.

I will now attempt to address some of the issues presented by certain commenters who obviously play as Angmar often and therefore wish to keep their primary enemies under control as much as possible.

Arnor as a effective nation is dead, but it is doubtless that the Rangers would have considered themselves Arnorians and that they were keeping the realm alive.

The mines are plausible, as many things were not mentioned by are implied. Tolkien would doubtlessly have thought that there were mines in Eriador, for Aragorn had a sword of Dúnedain make before he got Andúril and he could not possibly have been wielding a very old sword, as it would have rusted and snapped long before that time.

Added to that, the Hobbits had metal farming and digging implements, and they were mentioned to be rather isolationistic. Therefore, it stands to reason that Hobbits would have had mines, and by extension Eriador.

Eriador Militia is plausible, but would more appropriately be called Breelander Militia, as Bree was the last remaining settlement of any note left in Arnor.

Arnorian troops are entirely plausible and actually canon for this point in time. When the mod takes place, during the War of the Ring, the Rangers successfully take back much of their ancient lands, while Lóriën and Eryn Lasgalen destroy Dôl Guldur and Gondor and Rohan fight against Mordor.

Rangers would doubtlessly have reformed the old armies for this purpose, as light skirmishers like the Rangers were would not have been effective in open battle like they would have seen during that period. They would have melted down and remade any weapons caches they found and re-tempered the weapons, effectively remaking the Arnorians arms and armor.

Dúnedain smithies are entirely plausible, although I am not sure that they would have used Raven wings on their helms.

This is my argument for this suggestion. I hope, that even if it does not convince you, you begin to see the author's point.