Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-27200931-20170426224854/@comment-27912807-20170428115328

Ithillion, Idc that he said that they weren't elves anymore, THAT MAKES NO SENSE WHATSOEVER give me one theory excluding elves that could work then. JUST ONE! He can't create life so that isn't possible, the only way would be by mutating some other lifeform, but the only ones logical would be by taking either apes, or elves, but we have no clue if Morgoth would take the time to find Apes in the preumeably south, and torment them into Orcs, but that would mean he would make from Apes human-like creatures, and that would be impossible if Tolkien didn't believe in evolution, so only elves remain as a senseable option.