Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-98.247.21.9-20151112005331/@comment-26453572-20151112012526

Two problems with this.

1. Tolkien was a devout Catholic from a time where most people never considered this as okay, especially Catholics.

2. During the time this was based off of, having any attraction to the opposite gender, let alone being partners with one, was considered a terrible crime, and you would face a terrible death for being gay/lesbian.

So not only does it defy lore, but it would be unrealistic.