Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-25987328-20160413230109/@comment-26094355-20160423030742

Catfishperson wrote: This is also and interesting approach to the movie. LOL... you're going to try to use CinemaSins as some kind of source? CinemaSins??? Please tell me this is a joke.

You're trying to somehow put forward that a known dramatic, sometimes innaccurate, and overly flamboyant hate-train-YouTube-channel, is some kind of basis that The Hobbit movies are instantly trash? Know that they have a video for pretty much every major movie (even the LoTR films), and even ranging far beyond Middle-earth to other blockbuster films. Their job is to hate. With their logic, instantly all movies are trash (which is dangerously ignorant). But no creation, whether it be a film or even Tolkien's books, are perfect. Nothing is perfect, and I was never implying the films were.

But if you keep looking at what faults they had, you're never going to see that they did more right. And that's the problem here.

"18 minutes of faults" means nothing. The Hobbit films have 9 hours, per film, of behind the scenes, filled with logical, lore-friendly, and justifiable reasons for all these "faults". Nice try.

 Elvenking of the Woodland Realm