Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-26104026-20180718014248/@comment-26104026-20180721205843

Minecraftmage113 wrote: XD "Speled" is spelled wrong in the first sentance. That is hillarious. I approve :P

great ideas, though perhaps this is better suited to a separate mod... I dunno, its something that I feel like could fit in into other things that don't be LotR, though I will admit it fits in here very well.

hmm... how to improve... Honestly? It's very well done. I can't think of much more to make it better, though I will say that being able to, rather than simply make all your food better, also be able to cook it faster (though only at normal stats) might work nicely. There is the problem with stacking items if this were implemented though...

The only actual way I can think of to make it better is to create a very fast mini-game type bit in which you prepare the food/stuff and then can get a score slightly based off that making it so that new players aren't completely thrown. This would also apply to reforging and creating weapons as well. That means practice will be assured to improve your abilities, but also skill will help as well so that newbies aren't completely helpless, though even then it shouldn't be too big of a boost when it comes to combat items just so that completely new players still have a decent chance. As I said, new players should be fine. It's just that advanced players would be able to go beyond normal. A minigame might be nice, but it doesn't feel very lotr. I addressed stacking too; quality as a percentage can be averaged when stacked, so quality is assigned to stacks, not items. EXAMPLE" if you had 10 178% grapes and 3 105% grapes, if they are stacked, you get 13 161% grapes. That completely solves stacking. I think this does fit into LOTR because we see many professions in LOTR; smiths, farmers, bartenders, etc, and some are very clearly shown to be superior to others due to skill, wisdom, knowledge, etc. The mod is also based around geography, so making geography take a physical effect on the quality of items would only be natural.