Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-158.59.252.13-20160816194001/@comment-158.59.252.13-20160831215409

Solelfar wrote: Well once again a pointless debate, since it was posted on a LotR forum. If you had posted this on a Star Wars forum I bet everyone would have said Star Wars wins. Plus, is it because a character/universe/etc would win a death fight that it means it is better? And why would Melkor and Sauron win against Star Wars armies? Sauron could be defeated by Elendil and Gil Galad! Melkor was wounded by Fingolfin! Even if they are both immortal they can be defeated and neutralized. But finally, how can you even compare those two universes, with different rules, species, laws, divinities, etc... Star Wars universe is ruled by the concept of the Force. It has its own deities, two sides of the Force, beings of supernatural power, etc ... Luke is said to be the "Chosen One". So he was chosen by something, either a concept, such as the Force, or a divinity. In a place as the Star Wars universe, with its very own lore, would Ilúvatar still have created the whole universe? Or would Eä being only part of the Star Wars universe?

You see? If you go a bit further, you understand you cannot compare both. This was posted on the LotR website, yet a LOT of people are for Star Wars winning out here. And it is not just Melkor and Sauron. It is all the dieties in all of Arda! Why doesn't anyone get that?!! And don't you speak about Fingolfin like that! I bet, even with a regular sword, he might be able to defeat some of the lesser Jedi if they did not use the force. He might be able to dodge around them or something. This is not a pointless debate, as we have compared many other universes with LotR with a clear view of who would win?