Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-27320169-20151229190234/@comment-25333020-20160121212454

Heartgold1234 wrote:

TheblueWizard wrote:  1. It was most likely a later adition to his writings.

2. It's still a fair distance, it would be no simple task.

3. No, it wouldn't. Would you trade with some foreigner who set up shop in your back garden. They don't even speak the same language, and how can you be sure people live around there?

4. Evidence required. Oh look, there isn't any. That's a lie.

5. And what makes you think the Avari would help? They're isolationists. It's still not in some, so thinking about the way Tolkein was, saying he was a story teller, and not just making stuff up. I'm saying that he probably only found out later on :)

True...

The Free Easterlings are comprised of many different people. They would surly have at least one person who talked the same speech

Well, Saruman could control the weather, so why not the blue wizards? They could have devoted much of their time studying how to control the weather.

True, but even isolists help when the need is great (most times) like Thranduil. Anyway, how do we know they are isolists?