Board Thread:Suggestions forum/@comment-26847105-20160405120942/@comment-26322120-20160407003956

Aman wasn't simply in Arda, but "hidden," it was completely removed when the world was made round. The elven ships didn't have anything to do with getting there, the elves simply were the only ones who had knowledge of "The straight Path," the only way of accessing Aman. Because of this I always imagined that Aman would be a separate dimension only accessible by players with enough High Elven alignment.