Board Thread:Suggestions Forum/@comment-70.171.133.107-20141226164822/@comment-50.36.65.10-20150101020706

The Arkenstone couldn't have been a Silmaril, at least I don't think it could've been, because one, if I recall correctly, was cast deep into a chasm, incredibly deep and filled with fire, fire that had been burning since the first battles of the Valar and Melkor/Morgoth. That's some SCARY fire. The other, I believe, was cast into a deep sea trench. And the final one rides on the brow of Earendil, as he sails the heavens as a star during the night. (Or maybe on the prow of his ship...I don't remember which)