Board Thread:General Mod Discussion/@comment-34204318-20180104010701/@comment-31488041-20180109023612

I believe he means in the book although gwaihir does talk in both the only time we see the eagles talk in the hobbit is at their eyrie and in lotr when he's bearing Gandalf to lothlorien other than that would you talk whilst mid flight? I mean you wouldn't be able to get a single word out