FANDOM


  • please i love your mod and i want to do a Aternos server with this mod but Aternos just use mods from curse, so please put your mod in Curse 

      Loading editor
    • We had someone asking this about a week ago, and it really isn't necessary.

        Loading editor
    • Hey, I was actually wondering the same thing. Could you guys please put this mod on Curseforge? I'd probably attract more attention, grow the player base, and allow people like myself and the gentleman above to run Aternos servers. Thanks!

        Loading editor
    • 135.0.188.68 wrote:
      Hey, I was actually wondering the same thing. Could you guys please put this mod on Curseforge? I'd probably attract more attention, grow the player base, and allow people like myself and the gentleman above to run Aternos servers. Thanks!

      Growing the player base isn't really that helpful, sure, many new people would know the mod and play it, but on the other hand it could attract people who are like MCNaveed and don't know anything about Tolkien, the Canon, or anything else and have no desire to learn any thing about it and don't appreciate Mevans' work and always ask for Gandalf.

      Jurassic Sean of Tol Hîth Visit my Park!

        Loading editor
    • I would like the LotR mod to be available for Aternos.

        Loading editor
    • Jurassic Sean wrote:
      135.0.188.68 wrote:
      Hey, I was actually wondering the same thing. Could you guys please put this mod on Curseforge? I'd probably attract more attention, grow the player base, and allow people like myself and the gentleman above to run Aternos servers. Thanks!
      Growing the player base isn't really that helpful, sure, many new people would know the mod and play it, but on the other hand it could attract people who are like MCNaveed and don't know anything about Tolkien, the Canon, or anything else and have no desire to learn any thing about it and don't appreciate Mevans' work and always ask for Gandalf.

      Jurassic Sean of Tol Hîth Visit my Park!

      Eh, it's still a great mod, even without having an understanding of the lore. Probably wouldn't have gotten as into Tolkien as I am now if I hadn't had such a good time with this.

      That said, your mention of MCNaveed is very convincing. Didn't even bother to learn about the mod before reviewing it. Didn't mention the entire Middle-earth dimension. Didn't mention factions. Or alignment. Or brewing, or weapons, or anything.

        Loading editor
    • Yeah, I took a quick look at Naveed's videos, and they're just junk. I think he believed that this mod was just something that added a few Middle-earth NPC's, weapons, and generated structures into the Overworld, a.k.a. just a small addon, not a game-changer.

      22:44, March 7, 2019 (UTC)
        Loading editor
    • I get that a lot of people may not appreciate Tolkein or Mevan's work, but I think more exposure is always a good thing. This mod was one of the reasons why I began reading the Silmarillion and rereading many of the orginal works. Many people also want to play with this mod on servers, with services such as Aternos, and I for one would love to play with my friends on Aternos. Putting the mod on curseforge seems like a natural progression for me. 

        Loading editor
    • I actually really agree!

      It would add a simple way to track down a certain version of the mod. I've used curseforge for this numerous times, and I can really tell you it is useful!

      It really beats the hastle for new players to have to google the mod, going to random sites until they happen to find the latest version with a download that works.

      Please, PLEASE do this!

        Loading editor
    • Bit late to the party, but I certainly agree! I'd love to see this mod on curseforge (and by extension, available on aternos), and I'm sure being able to host a free server on the mod would attract a lot of new players.

      I don't see a problem with less knowledgeable people playing this mod, or even making videos about it. We were all newbies at one point.

      Part of me wants to highlight this thread, but I feel like that might be mod power abuse...

        Loading editor
    • In my opinion, putting the mod on CurseForge isn't such a bad idea. Most people, not just in the Minecraft community, but in the general public as a whole. Do not even have a clue about Tolkien and his works, even for a player like me who has been a fan of the mod for quite a long time.

      I struggle to remember to dig into the Updates section of the Wikia to find the latest update, even then I forget that the bug fixes must be downloaded on the Facebook page only. I couldn't even begin to imagine what it is like for a user who has never even heard of Tolkien, to even know where to start with the mod.

      Therefore, I don't see any harm in posting it on CurseForge, it will only increase our playerbase if anything. Although, I could be wrong, someone correct me if this is the case. Thank you.

      - Sincerely, Lumornion, your fellow Wikia user

        Loading editor
    • Yeah, you're certainly right. That being said, the mod still seems like it'd be super enjoyable,e even for someone who has never read the books or even watched the movies. They might not understand certain references/speechbanks, but the gameplay as a whole should still be understandable to non-Tolkien fans.

        Loading editor
    • Most of the mods I download other than this one are from CurseForge. There really isn't a problem with putting this mod there IMO.

      That doesn't mean you won't get a few reviews of the mod that are factually inaccurate, or not true to the lore, but, in general, they will not likely be the ones that attract the most attention.

      10:59, August 11, 2019 (UTC)
        Loading editor
    • And even if they do attract a lot of attention, there's a lot of Tolkien fans out there, and they're probably gonna be corrected sooner rather than later.

        Loading editor
    • And any publicity is good publicity? I don't think it matters if someone gives an ill-informed review of the mod if they end up attracting more players to it.


        Loading editor
    • Yeah. And like I said, there's plenty of people out there to correct misinformation. I took a look at MCNaveed's cringy videos, and you don't need to scroll down very far to see comments pointing out the various inaccuracies/omissions. 

      PedeIcon

        Loading editor
    • Jurassic Sean wrote:
      135.0.188.68 wrote:
      Hey, I was actually wondering the same thing. Could you guys please put this mod on Curseforge? I'd probably attract more attention, grow the player base, and allow people like myself and the gentleman above to run Aternos servers. Thanks!
      Growing the player base isn't really that helpful, sure, many new people would know the mod and play it, but on the other hand it could attract people who are like MCNaveed and don't know anything about Tolkien, the Canon, or anything else and have no desire to learn any thing about it and don't appreciate Mevans' work and always ask for Gandalf.

      Jurassic Sean of Tol Hîth Visit my Park!

      Wow, why do i hear funeral bells? Gatekkeeping is the surest and most insidious symptom of death in existence, in the last few years i saw this community grow increasingly more insular and resistant to change but this is a new low.

        Loading editor
    • One thing I am curious about is whether or not the mod's complexity will make putting it on curseforge a more difficult job.

        Loading editor
    • Well I have looked at Multiple Videos that Youtubers who don't give two about looking at the mod and putting Lotr in curse will attract so many more that will complain about Main Structures and that crap My point No just no

      And These Crappy Youtubers will Multiply by a thousand if Mevans puts it in Curse

      Also These New People Will Not give two about Mevans opinion and ask for updating Mod Versions

        Loading editor
    • Foeslayer12 wrote:
      Well I have looked at Multiple Videos that Youtubers who don't give two about looking at the mod and putting Lotr in curse will attract so many more that will complain about Main Structures and that crap My point No just no

      And These Crappy Youtubers will Multiply by a thousand if Mevans puts it in Curse

      Also These New People Will Not give two about Mevans opinion and ask for updating Mod Versions

      "We must not put the mod on Curse. It will attract NEW PEOPLE. Oh the horror, and even worse those new people may not worship the mod or it's creator as much as i do, filthy heretics"

      Are you aware of how unhinged you sound? Get a grip people, it's a mod, for a game, not a second coming, granted it's a very good mod for a very good game but some people in this thread are treating it more like a cult then a fandom, and that's a bad sign.

        Loading editor
    • Hi there, i just found this thread out while tried to found out the reason of not putting that mod on the CurseForge. Curiously enough i need this because of Aternos just as founder of the topic. Well, sadly to see that started about a half-year ago and still gave out nothing. Neither yes nor even a solid no (please dont put there a solid no, itll break my heart).

      Curseforge is handy, useful and comfortable bank of most of the mods for Minecraft. As said many times already, it might attract many new auditory, count us Atrenos players at least! And the ignoramuses? As also said, all we were newbies, and also all we can lead others to stop being newbies. There are already people who overask about updating, we still can ignore or teach them if they will increase in numbers.

      Put the Lord of the Rings Mod for Minecraft in CurseForge, please, and sorry if i have terrible grammar.

        Loading editor
    • I am not saying that new people are bad I am saying that these people on Curse are VERY complainy Belive me I have a mod on it and I entirely reget it.

      They say things like Update the Mod verison My God its Stupid just saying Mevs You will reget it

        Loading editor
    • Foeslayer12 wrote:
      I am not saying that new people are bad I am saying that these people on Curse are VERY complainy Belive me I have a mod on it and I entirely reget it.

      They say things like Update the Mod verison My God its Stupid just saying Mevs You will reget it

      I download from Curse all the time, exposure naturally brings a few complainers and impatient people, it is wholly unfair to paiint the entire usebase of curse with the same brush, many of my favorite mods are on curse and none of them ever complained about the site, in fact Curse is widely regarded as the only place to download mods in good standing.

        Loading editor
    • Foeslayer12 wrote:
      Well I have looked at Multiple Videos that Youtubers who don't give two about looking at the mod and putting Lotr in curse will attract so many more that will complain about Main Structures and that crap My point No just no

      And These Crappy Youtubers will Multiply by a thousand if Mevans puts it in Curse

      Also These New People Will Not give two about Mevans opinion and ask for updating Mod Versions

      Newbies are a part of every forum, hobby, sport and community in existence. No one started anything as an expert - I bet we all asked stupid questions about something we didn't know better about. To the experienced, newbies and their questions may be annoying at best and downright cringy at worst, but without them, the community is doomed to die. 

      PedeIcon

        Loading editor
    • LysurusPeriphragmoides789 wrote:
      Foeslayer12 wrote:
      Well I have looked at Multiple Videos that Youtubers who don't give two about looking at the mod and putting Lotr in curse will attract so many more that will complain about Main Structures and that crap My point No just no

      And These Crappy Youtubers will Multiply by a thousand if Mevans puts it in Curse

      Also These New People Will Not give two about Mevans opinion and ask for updating Mod Versions

      Newbies are a part of every forum, hobby, sport and community in existence. No one started anything as an expert - I bet we all asked stupid questions about something we didn't know better about. To the experienced, newbies and their questions may be annoying at best and downright cringy at worst, but without them, the community is doomed to die. 

      PedeIcon

      Unless of course, the apocalypse arrived and everything technology related was shut down.

        Loading editor
    • Foeslayer12 wrote: I am not saying that new people are bad I am saying that these people on Curse are VERY complainy Belive me I have a mod on it and I entirely reget it.

      They say things like Update the Mod verison My God its Stupid just saying Mevs You will reget it

      Try to disable commentaries xD. Or set there a big disclaimer of things you dont want to read.

      I dont think Curse's users are the only with such a complainance, i've seen that kind of people there as well.

        Loading editor
    • I'm kinda thinking of highlighting this thread to get more attention. Do you think it's worth it?

        Loading editor
    • No

        Loading editor
    • LysurusPeriphragmoides789 wrote:
      I'm kinda thinking of highlighting this thread to get more attention. Do you think it's worth it?

      Yes.

        Loading editor
    • Yes indeed!

        Loading editor
    • Thanks guys, I'll do it. (If I can remember how to)

      Edit: for some reason the option isn't showing up

        Loading editor
    • The highlighting feature was removed back in December iirc.

      MilkBucket MilkMC Send me your crash reports, Fandom User.MilkBucket

        Loading editor
    • Samoja1 wrote:
      Foeslayer12 wrote:
      I am not saying that new people are bad I am saying that these people on Curse are VERY complainy Belive me I have a mod on it and I entirely reget it.

      They say things like Update the Mod verison My God its Stupid just saying Mevs You will reget it

      I download from Curse all the time, exposure naturally brings a few complainers and impatient people, it is wholly unfair to paiint the entire usebase of curse with the same brush, many of my favorite mods are on curse and none of them ever complained about the site, in fact Curse is widely regarded as the only place to download mods in good standing.

      A few!?

        Loading editor
    • Foeslayer12 wrote:
      Samoja1 wrote:
      Foeslayer12 wrote:
      I am not saying that new people are bad I am saying that these people on Curse are VERY complainy Belive me I have a mod on it and I entirely reget it.

      They say things like Update the Mod verison My God its Stupid just saying Mevs You will reget it

      I download from Curse all the time, exposure naturally brings a few complainers and impatient people, it is wholly unfair to paiint the entire usebase of curse with the same brush, many of my favorite mods are on curse and none of them ever complained about the site, in fact Curse is widely regarded as the only place to download mods in good standing.
      A few!?

      Yes, if the mod has hundrefs of thousands or even millions of downloads a few dozen or even hundred people who complain or demand stuff is a tiny, tiny minority.

        Loading editor
    • Tbh, this debate has gone off trail for some time now. Can someone who is in charge please put this to a conclusion?

        Loading editor
    • Lumornion wrote:
      Tbh, this debate has gone off trail for some time now. Can someone who is in charge please put this to a conclusion?

      I agree anyone Grev or any admin

        Loading editor
    • Hey guys. I've used the mod previously, and I really enjoyed it. I'm now trying to get it to work in a curseforge modpack right now, but it doesn't seem to be working. It's probably because it's a non-Curse mod. I'm disappointed that the mod isn't working, because I really did enjoy it. I think having the mod as a mod on Curseforge rather than an external installation might help, and I support the mod's transistion onto CurseForge.

        Loading editor
    • It could be that the latest update broke the mod's compatibility with other mods in the pack. The developer doesn't really prioritise this mod's compatibility with others, and develops it mainly as a standalone mod. Slightly unfortunate, but it means greater freedom on his end.

      11:21, October 3, 2019 (UTC)
        Loading editor
    • man id love to play this mod with my friends, we all love tolkien, but servers are expensive and the only way we can play is via aternos can you guys upload the mod to curseforge please?

        Loading editor
    • As of today, the renewed (1.15) version of the mod is available on CurseForge here.

        Loading editor
    • I FUCKING LOVE YOU GUYS OMG

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.