Yet this is held true by the wise of Eressëa, that all those of the Quendi who came into the hands of Melkor, ere Utumno was broken, were put there in prison, and by slow arts of cruelty were corrupted and enslaved; and thus did Melkor breed the hideous race of the Orcs in envy and mockery of the Elves, of whom they were afterwards the bitterest foes.

The Silmarillion, Of the Coming of the Elves and the Captivity of Melkor

Tormented Elves are NPCs that spawn in the obsidian and fire layers of Utumno.

Upon killing a tormented elf, the player earns the achievement "The Forgotten".


Tormented Elves are the ancestors of every Orc that plagues Middle-Earth.

In the First Age when the Elves were yet young as a race, Melkor captured many Elves and imprisoned them. After being tortured and shut off from all slightly things, they became the Orcs that Melkor (and later Sauron and Saruman) used in their many wars against the Free Peoples of Middle-Earth.


Like all Utumno NPCs, these Elves will only spawn in Utumno, but only on the second and third floors.


The tormented Elves, being under the power of the Dark Lord Melkor, will attack any NPC or player that enters their vicinity.

However, they will sometimes speak to the player while they fight. Some of their speeches include sentences of help, some of the Elves apparently mistake the player for Melkor, but other sentences are more Orcish in nature. The reason for these differences in speech is because these Elves are partly Orcish and partly Elvish. These elves are very sad and gloomy, similar to the Núrn slaves. The look of these creatures can vary. Some look almost completely orcish but others look more of elf kind; many are in between. Attempts to save them from their wretched existence will fail, and the only way to help them is to grant them freedom in The Halls of Mandos...


Tormented Elves can drop one or two Elf bones upon death, some arrows, and on occasion one of the weapons they wielded. Tormented elves that spawn in the Obsidian level have a chance to drop Obsidian Key Parts, while those on the Fire level have a chance to drop the Pickaxe of the Underworld.



  • Please... help... us!
  • There is no escape from this darkness. There is no hope.
  • Man-flesh! Give me Man-flesh! No... no! What am I saying?
  • He promised wealth... He promised power... He said He would let us go...
  • I cannot unsee it. I will never forget the terrible glare of His eyes. Please, let us go!
  • Help us! Please help us! We cannot endure any more!
  • Who are you? How did you come here? There is no hope in this place. You will succumb to the darkness.
  • He took us away. He tortured us. He turned many into those foul Orcs! He will not turn me! No!
  • No, no, no! This cannot be! You are just another one of His puppets sent to torture us! Leave us alone!
  • What... who... how? Do you come to free us from our torment?
  • His glare is ever upon us... you cannot escape it. You will die!
  • Flesh! I want flesh! Flesh!
  • I must serve Him. I must obey Him.
  • We must obey... We must serve...
  • The darkness shall consume you. You cannot escape it.
  • Do you come to torture us?
  • How could you enter the darkness of Utumno? There is no hope here. You shall soon join us in our suffering.
  • You shall fall, wretched creature of light!
  • Do you come from Him, to torment us further? No! I shall not allow it!
  • How many more thousands of years must I languish in these depths?
  • No light... nothing but screams and shadow...
  • There is no way out! None!
  • Your spirit shall linger in Utumno until the breaking of the world!
  • What hope you had in escaping is long gone. You will be consumed by the Shadow.
  • Your soul shall be trapped down here until the end of time!
  • You will soon succumb to the darkness of Utumno.
  • Man-flesh! Sweet and juicy Man-flesh! I can smell it!
  • There is no light that can defeat the Shadow.
Balrog  The Armies of Utumno  Melkor Plate

(Located under Forodwaith, after walking through the Pits)


First Floor: Ice SpiderOrc (Archer) • Warg (Ice)
Second Floor: Orc (Archer) • Tormented ElfTrollWarg (Obsidian)
Third Floor: BalrogOrc (Archer) • Tormented ElfTrollWarg (Fire)

Armour & Equipment:

ArmourBalrog WhipEquipmentPickaxe of the Underworld


First Floor: Ice Brick (Glowing) • Ice Pillar
Second Floor: Obsidian Brick (Fiery) • Obsidian Pillar
Third Floor: Fire Brick (Burning)• Fire Pillar


KeyMelkor PlateFlame of UdûnChill of Daedelos

Start a Discussion Discussions about Tormented Elf

  • [Closed:Expired] Eldhemir and the forgotten

    12 messages
    • MrHobit1234 wrote:I believe this is a known no go, I could be wrong though. those typically last a tad bit less
    • I was just reading the part of the Silmarillion about Turin, and it does mention that some elves escaped from Angband my mining tunnels, so ma...
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.